Ivermectin vs Other Antiparasitic Drugs: Effectiveness and Comparisons

 Ivermectin vs Other Antiparasitic Drugs | Clinical Trials | World Health Organization | Human Diseases | Blood Brain Barrier | Severe Malaria | Disease Control | Use of Ivermectin |

Ivermectin has proven its significance in treating a broad spectrum of parasitic diseases. The FDA approved Ivermectin for humans to treat parasitic infections caused by parasitic worms, whipworms, and hookworms. The antiparasitic drug targets a varied range of parasites, including those causing strongyloidiasis, onchocerciasis, lymphatic filariasis, and scabies. The antiviral effect of oral Ivermectin has been shown effective against a wide range of DNA and RNA viruses, including Zika, dengue, and yellow fever, among others.

Importance of Comparing ivermectin to Other Antiparasitic Drugs

Common antiparasitic medications include Ivermectin, Praziquantel, Metronidazole, Mebendazole, and Albendazole. These drugs are prescribed for the treatment of a diverse range of parasitic infections such as worms and protozoa for human use. Ivermectin is prominent for its broad-spectrum activity against parasites including nematodes. Mebendazole and Albendazole are used for the treatment of several helminth infections. Metronidazole is prescribed to treat mainly protozoal infections and certain bacterial infections. Proziquantel is used to treat tapeworm infections.

Mechanism of Action

How Ivermectin Works Against Parasites

Ivermectin treatment works against helminths or parasitic worms by targeting the chloride channels that are sensitive to the neurotransmitter glutamate. Through this activity, Ivermectin hinders the normal function in the central nervous system of the parasite causing paralysis and then death of the parasite.

Mechanisms for Other Antiparasitic Drugs (Anthelmintics)

Albendazole: Albendazole works by binding tubulin in infection-causing parasitic worms. The drug does it with extreme avidity than the tubulin in mammalian cells, however, some extent of toxicity of benzimidazoles may be associated with this activity. It prevents the worm from absorbing sugar making them lose energy and die.

Mebendazole: Mebendazole works by constraining microtubule production through binding to the colchicine-binding site of beta-tubulin that blocks the polymerization of tubulin dimers in the intestinal cells of parasites.

Praziquantel: Praziquantel disturbs calcium ion homeostasis in worms and the current accord that antagonizes voltage-gated calcium channels. This disruption causes unrestrained calcium ion influx leading to uninhibited muscle contraction and paralysis. It causes severe spasms and paralysis in the muscles of the worm.

Efficacy of Ivermectin

Ivermectin is an anthelmintic used to treat onchocerciasis (river blindness), strongyloidiasis (intestinal infection by threadworms), and other worm infections. Ivermectin tablets interfere with the nerve and muscle function of infection causing worms to paralyze and destroy them.

Onchocerciasis

Onchocerciasis is also known as river blindness. It is a parasitic infection caused by Onchocerca volvulus (filarial worm) carried through bites of infected black flies. These flies breed near fast-flowing streams and rivers. It causes severe wye problems and skin issues and may lead to blindness. Onchocerciasis is majorly found in Yemen, Sub-Saharan Africa, and certain regions of South and Central America.

River blindness symptoms include:

  • Intense itching
  • Skin rashes
  • Changed skin pigmentation
  • Nodules under skin
  • Eye lesions and inflammation
  • Vision impairment
  • Low vision
  • Permanent blindness
  • Enlarged lymph nodes
  • Neurological concerns (rare)

Onchocerciasis is diagnosed by detecting microfilariae or immature worms in the skin samples or by identifying adult worms in the skin nodules. A single dose of Ivermectin can significantly treat the condition and prevent possible complications, as demonstrated in clinical trials. In endemic regions, Ivermectin is generally administered to the whole population through Mass Drug administration (MDA) programs for effective management of the disease. Controlling the black fly breeding and population can significantly prevent onchocerciasis transmission.

Lymphatic filariasis

Lymphatic filariasis is also known as elephantiasis. The parasitic infection is caused by microscopic worms that are transmitted through mosquito bites. It causes swelling in the limbs, genitals, and other parts of the body and it may lead to permanent disability. Elephantiasis is caused by filarial worms including Brugia malayi, Brugia timori, and Wuchereria bancrofti.

These parasitic worms are transmitted to humans through infected mosquito bites. The larvae transmitted by mosquitoes transfer to the lymphatic vessels and here they mature into adult worms. Then they produce numerous larvae and get circulated in the blood continuing the cycle of transmission. Lymphatic filariasis is categorized as a neglected tropical disease as it majorly infects impoverished communities and may cause significant illness and disability.

Symptoms include:

  • Lymphedema (swelling in legs, arms, genitals or breasts)
  • Elephantiasis (disfigurement and disability)
  • Hydrocele (swelling of the scrotum in males)
  • Thickening or hardening of the skin
  • Persistent wheezing or coughing
  • Shortness of breath

The key treatment for this disease is medication that kills parasitic worms such as Ivermectin. Lymphatic filariasis can be prevented by avoiding mosquito bites, taking precautions to protect yourself from mosquito bites, and using mosquito repellents.

Scabies

Scabies are a spreadable skin infection. It is caused by tiny mites that hide under the skin. Female mites hide in the skin, lay eggs, and live there for many weeks. It causes rash and intense itching. The rashes appear as small pimple-like bumps. It can be easily transmitted through direct skin-to-skin contact and by sharing infected clothing or bedding stuff.

Symptoms of scabies include:

  • Intense itching that may feel worse at night
  • Pimple-like rashed or thread-like tracks on armpits, wrists, between fingers, and around the groin
  • Some people may have sores because of scratching

The primary treatment for scabies is topical Permethrin cream which kills mites and their eggs. Oral medication such as ivermectin is prescribed if topical treatment is unable to work. Especially in the case of crusted scabies and for people with lowered immune systems, Ivermectin is preferred.

Comparison with Other Antiparasitic Drugs

Various antiparasitic drugs work differently to treat a range of infections. Let’s see how Ivermectin differs from other antiparasitic medications, especially in the context of neglected tropical diseases.

Albendazole

This antiparasitic drug is prescribed to treat various worm infections. It works by stopping the sugar absorption by the worm, which makes the worm lose energy and eventually causes death. Albendazole is a prescription drug. It is used for the treatment of neurocysticercosis, a nervous system infection caused by pork tapeworms. It is also prescribed to treat cystic hydatid disease of the lung, liver, and peritoneum (tapeworm infection).

Side effects:

Along with the benefits, medicine may also cause some adverse reactions. Although these side effects are not bothersome and go away in a few days, if they persist they may necessitate medical attention.

  • Fever
  • Chills
  • Cough
  • Black stools
  • Bleeding gums
  • Chest pain
  • Sore throat
  • Painful urination
  • Swollen glands

Praziquantel

The anthelmintic drug is used for the treatment of worm infections. It works by inducing severe spasms and paralysis of the muscles of the worm. Praziquantel is prescribed to treat schistosomiasis or snail fever, a urinary tract or bowel infection caused by a flatworm parasite (Schistosoma or blood fluke).

The exact mode of action is not known but evidence shows that Praziquantel increases the permeability of schistosome cell membranes toward calcium ions. Thereby the drug causes contraction in the muscles of the parasite leading to paralysis.

Side effects:

  • Racing heart
  • Fever or ill feeling
  • Breathing problems
  • Wheezing
  • Swollen lymph nodes
  • Swelling of throat, mouth, tongue, lips or face
  • Throat tightness or swallowing trouble
  • Nausea or vomiting
  • Itching, pale red bumps or skin rash

Nitazoxanide

The prescription medication Nitazoxanide belongs to antiprotozoal. It is prescribed to treat diarrhea caused by certain protozoa, one-celled organisms. It is prescribed for adults and children above one year of age. Protozoa are diagnosed as the cause of diarrhea if diarrhea lasts more than a week. It blocks the enzyme (pyruvate ferredoxin oxidoreductase) that is necessary for energy metabolism in certain parasites.

Side effects:

  • Stomach pain
  • Nausea
  • Headache
  • Discolored urine

Mebendazole

Mebendazole is prescribed to treat various worm infections caused by whipworms, pinworms, hookworms, and roundworms. It belongs to anthelmintics and is only available with a doctor’s prescription. It prevents the worm from absorbing glucose which makes it lose energy and leads to the death of the worm. Mebendazole treats common roundworms (ascariasis), hookworms (ancylostomiasis, necatoriasis, uncinariasis), whipworms (trichuriasis) and pinworms (oxyuriasis, enterobiasis).

Side effects:

  • Abdominal pain
  • Diarrhea
  • Nausea
  • Vomiting
  • Loss of appetite
  • Headache
  • Flatulence
  • Tinnitus
  • Elevated liver enzymes

Use Cases and Treatment Guidelines

Topical Ivermectin | Breast Cancer Cell Proliferation | Cutaneous Larva Migrans | Administred Orally | Cutaneous Leishmaniasis | Potent Anthelmintic Agents | Combination therapy |

Ivermectin the wonder drug is the primary treatment for river blindness or onchocerciasis, strongyloidiasis, and other worm infections. It is an anthelmintic that interferes with the nerve and muscle function of parasitic worms and paralyzes them leading to the death of the parasite, which is crucial in treating various infectious diseases .

When the standard treatment fails to treat the infection or resistance occurs, alternative parasitic medications are considered.  Moreover, alternative drugs may be prescribed when standard treatments are unavailable or have notable side effects.

Drug resistance:

Many parasites including fungi and bacteria may develop resistance to certain parasitic drugs leading to the failure or inefficiency of the standard treatments. For instance, some malaria parasites have developed resistance to chloroquine and other typical antimalarials. In such cases, alternative medications with different modes of action are preferred.  

Treatment Failure:

In some cases, patients don’t respond to the primary treatment, so alternative antiparasitic options are considered. It may happen due to various reasons such as co-existing infections, suboptimal dosage of the drug, or incorrect diagnosis. Further investigation or alternative medications can help such patients.

Significant Side Effects:

Some standard antiparasitic medications may have considerable side effects making them unsuitable for certain patients. For instance, Benznidazole and Nifurtimox for the treatment of Trypanosoma cruzi infection may lead to high toxicity in certain patients. In such situations, alternative drugs with fewer side effects need to be preferred.

Limited Reachability:

In some areas, certain indicated antiparasitic drugs may not be readily available or affordable for every patient. It can be because of high costs, logistical challenges, or import restrictions. In these cases, alternative drugs are preferred that are easily assessable and affordable to each patient.  

Particular Parasitic Infections:

Certain parasitic infections may necessitate precise drug approaches that are not easily available in typical treatments. For instance, Hydatid disease may need alternative anti-hydatid drugs because of limited treatment options. Similarly, cysticercosis may need alternative medications such as Oxfendazole.

Combination Therapies:

For certain infections, combining various antiparasitic drugs or using antiparasitic medications in combination with other drugs (anti-inflammatory agents) can be necessary. Combination treatments can address multiple aspects of the infection, improve outcomes, and reduce the risk of resistance.

Resistance Considerations

Ivermectin resistance is a rising concern, especially in veterinary medicine. Although it’s less frequent in humans resistance in headlice and scabies mites has been noticed. The development of Ivermectin resistance is influenced by certain factors including repeated exposure to antiparasitic drugs, biological features of parasites, and genetic diversity.

Mechanism of Resistance:

  • Modifications in the membrane transporter, P glycoprotein can pump Ivermectin out of the parasitic cells reducing its efficiency.
  • Mutations in the genes encoding Ligand-Gated Ion Channel subunits which are targeted by Ivermectin can contribute to resistance.
  • Increased appearance of of drug-metabolizing enzymes can cause Ivermectin degradation reducing its effectiveness.
  • ATP-Binding Cassette transporter genes have a significant role in Ivermectin resistance as they actively transport the drug out of the cell.
  • Studies reveal that Ivermectin may impact additional pathways beyond its key action on glutamate-gated chloride channels probably contributing to varied resistance mechanisms.

Impacts and Concerns of Resistance

  • Ivermectin treatment results resistance in to veterinary parasites and is prevalent and a considerable concern for veterinary medicine and agricultural productivity.
  • Although Ivermectin resistance is less common in human medicine, ectoparasites (headlice and scabies mites) raise challenges for treatment success.
  • While the extensive Ivermectin use in human onchocerciasis programs is generally effective, elevates the likelihood of development of resistance over time.
  • The appearance of Ivermectin resistance in several parasitic groups underscores the necessity of proper monitoring and strategies to alleviate its spread.

Strategies to Mitigate Ivermectin Resistance

Using the safe highest dosage regimens can ensure effective treatment and reduce the likelihood of resistance. Combination therapies involving Ivermectin and anthelmintics or other drug classes can delay the occurrence of resistance. Taking proper sanitation measures and maintaining hygiene practices can prevent parasite transmission and reduce the requirement for drug interventions minimizing selection pressure. Ongoing research is essential for comprehending the mechanisms of resistance and developing new strategies to control and manage parasitic infections.

Safety Profiles and Side Effects

Ivermectin may cause some side effects in certain people including skin reactions, gastrointestinal problems, and neurological issues. These are temporary undesirable effects associated with taking ivermectin and usually don’t require any treatment. In case the side effects persist or become worse over time, seek your doctor’s advice immediately.

Common side effects associated with Ivermectin and other antiparasitic drugs include:

  • Allergic reactions
  • Dizziness
  • Weakness
  • Nausea
  • Vomiting
  • Stomach pain
  • Bloating
  • Diarrhea
  • Constipation
  • Loss of appetite
  • Headache
  • Liver toxicity

Contraindications and Special Populations

Typically, oral Ivermectin is contraindicated in children below 5 years of age and pregnant females majority because of safety concerns such as potential side effects. Pregnant women are generally excluded from Mass drug administration campaigns, which may also include treatments for conditions like head lice.

Children below 5 years: The safety and effectiveness of ivermectin have not been established in this age group and there may be concerns regarding the potential toxicity at lower doses. Always consult a healthcare provider before using this medicine on kids.

Pregnancy: Although some studies have not shown an increased risk of significant birth defects from inadvertent exposure, the inadequate safety evaluation and the probability of teratogenicity in animal studies direct against the use of this drug during pregnancy.

Future Directions in Antiparasitic Treatment

Ongoing research and developments in antiparasitic drug discovery are directed at finding new targets, making use of advanced technologies, and creating new therapeutic strategies including repurposing of existing medications. Researchers are hunting for new biochemical and molecular targets in parasites that can be used for medicine production. It includes exploiting the latest technologies to recognize potential drug targets and predict protein structures.

Exploring the probability of making use of existing drugs for other infections as potential antiparasitic agents. Searching for bioactive molecules from natural sources including plants and microbes is a considerable part of research. Using combination treatments to overcome drug resistance and enhance treatment outcomes is also being explored. Developing new methods to deliver medications efficiently to target parasites is vital for improved treatment success.

The Role of New Formulations and Delivery Methods

Ongoing research in antiparasitic drug discovery is focused on various aspects while addressing host toxicity, drug resistance, and fighting parasitic diseases. Fresh antiparasitic formulations and delivery methods are essential for improving the effectiveness, reducing toxicity, and enhancing patients’ compliance with existing medications.

New formulations can increase drug bioavailability and the extent of drug absorption. It can be achieved by capturing drugs within nanoparticles that can improve their absorption and solubility. New delivery methods can reduce the systemic exposure of medication by focusing on particular sites of infection reducing potential off-target effects and adverse effects. New developments can improve patient compliance by allowing easier administration through topical applications or sustained-release formulations that need less frequent dosing.

Conclusion

Ivermectin is a broad-spectrum anti-parasitic drug used to fight and treat parasitic worms in human medicine as well as veterinary medicine. It is prescribed for the treatment of various parasitic infections including parasitic worms, whipworms, and hookworms. Ivermectin has shown its effectiveness in combating many parasitic diseases when used as it is or in combination with other antiparasitic medications.

Ivermectin targets a wide range of parasites such as those causing lymphatic filariasis, strongyloidiasis, onchocerciasis, and scabies. Informed treatment decisions customized to individual patient necessities are vital for effective and ethical healthcare. It allows active patient care considering their autonomy and ensuring aligned decisions with their preferences and satisfaction. This approach strengthens the clinician-patient relationship and leads to improved outcomes and patient gratification.

References

Ivermectin has shown significant reductions in mortality, clinical recovery, and viral clearance in some meta-analyses of randomized controlled trials. Studies show Ivermectin can diminish the risk of contracting Covid-19. A Cochrane review determined the efficiency and safety of ivermectin are uncertain in Covid 19 thus the World Health Organization recommended its use in clinical trials only for patients infected .